My doctor's office readings kept running high, so he asked me to check at home twice a day for a few weeks and bring the log in. That was the start of all this. I walked out of that office with a note scribbled on the back of an appointment card and no idea what monitor to buy. My first one was a wrist cuff I picked up without asking anybody a single question. It read one thing before coffee and something else after supper, and I could not tell you which one to believe, so after ten days I put it back in the box and went back to guessing. My husband Gene is 70. I am Beverly, 67, and we live in a small one-story house in Lawton, Oklahoma. We share one monitor because we share the same routine: feet flat, arm resting on the kitchen table, morning before coffee and evening after supper. The Withings BPM Connect is the one that made the log easy for us. The Omron Gold is the one that feels like the monitor a lot of people already know from the pharmacy shelf. This is a plain comparison, not a diagnosis. Whatever you buy, the readings go to your doctor.
Here is the short answer. If you want your morning and evening readings to land in one place without writing them down twice, the Withings BPM Connect is the better fit. It syncs over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to the Health Mate app, and the cuff is listed for arms from 22 to 42 cm. If you want a monitor you can use without an app or an account, and you like the idea of seeing the box on a pharmacy shelf and asking a pharmacist about it before you pay, the Omron Gold is the better fit. Both are upper-arm automatic monitors. Neither one replaces your doctor, and neither one tells you what your numbers mean. The right one is the one you will actually use twice a day for three weeks straight, including the mornings you are running late and the evenings you would rather just go to bed. I compared them the way I use a monitor, not the way a lab does: the cuff range, the display, how the readings get saved, what comes in the box, the warranty, and how much I have to do before I can take a reading in the morning.
| Withings BPM Connect | Omron Gold | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Upper-arm automatic blood pressure monitor, FDA cleared, with an LCD display. | Upper-arm automatic blood pressure monitor from a name that has been on pharmacy shelves for years. |
| Cuff range | Band size 22-42 cm, listed for arm use. | Cuff range is printed on the box; check it against your arm before you buy. |
| Getting readings to your doctor | Syncs over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to the Health Mate app, so the log sits in one place. | The reading shows on the device; you write it in a notebook or use an app if you choose. |
| On-device display | LCD display with color-coded feedback. | The reading appears on the built-in screen and you never have to pick up a phone. |
| Setup | Needs the Health Mate app plus a Wi-Fi or Bluetooth connection before you get the syncing benefit. | Works on its own without an app or an account. |
| Power | Battery powered, with a charger included. | Battery powered; check the box for what comes with it. |
| Warranty | 2 year manufacturer warranty. | Warranty varies by model and by retailer. |
| Best for | A shared kitchen-table routine where you want the log handled for you. | A simple on-device routine with no app at all. |
Where Withings BPM Connect Wins
The Withings BPM Connect wins on the part I used to hate: writing the numbers down. Here is what it looked like before. I would take a reading, set the cuff on the table, and then go hunting for the little booklet I keep in the kitchen drawer. The drawer has a cheese slicer, three kinds of twine, and the booklet somewhere under all of it. By the time I found a pen I had forgotten whether the first number was 128 or 132, so I would write down 130 and call it close enough, which is not a log, it is a guess with a date on it. Two weeks of that and my doctor would have been reading my handwriting as much as my blood pressure. The BPM Connect syncs over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to the Health Mate app, so the reading is saved the moment I take it. I do not copy anything twice and I do not round anything off. When he asked for a few weeks of morning and evening readings, I opened the app at the table, scrolled back to the first day, and read the whole stretch out to him. The cuff is listed for arms from 22 to 42 cm, which is wide enough that Gene and I share it without changing anything but the wrap. The display is an LCD with color-coded feedback, so I can see where the reading landed without reaching for my glasses. The monitor is battery powered, a charger is included, and it weighs 12.8 ounces and measures 6.1 by 2.36 by 2.16 inches, so it lives in that same kitchen drawer without crowding out the twine. The listing also notes a 2 year manufacturer warranty and stainless steel in the materials.
The other thing the Withings BPM Connect wins on is the shared routine. Gene and I do not need two monitors. We need one cuff, one chair, one table, and one log we can both carry to our doctor. The app keeps our readings together, and the 22 to 42 cm band covers both of us, so the only thing that changes between his turn and mine is how far the cuff wraps. I like that it is automatic and upper arm, because that is the kind my doctor asked for and the kind I could never get right with the wrist cuff. I like that it is FDA cleared and portable, so I can carry it from the kitchen to the bedroom on a cold morning without unplugging anything or moving furniture. This is small until you have lived it: the Withings runs on batteries, so there is no cord stretched across the table waiting to catch a coffee cup. The charger stays in the drawer until the battery needs it. That one detail is why the monitor sits out on the table some evenings instead of going back in the drawer. It is not the simplest way to take a reading. It is the way that made me stop skipping the evening check, and a monitor you skip is a monitor that does nothing for you.
Where Omron Gold Wins
The Omron Gold wins on the first five minutes. If you are the kind of person who wants to put batteries in, wrap the cuff, and press start, the Omron Gold asks less of you. It is an upper-arm monitor from a brand that has sat on pharmacy shelves for a long time, and it works on its own without an app or an account. You do not need to pair a phone before you can check your arm in the morning. For a lot of people in my age group that is not a small thing. I watched a friend of mine bring a new monitor home, get as far as a password screen, and leave the whole thing in the box on top of her microwave for a month. She is not bad with technology either. She just did not want a project, she wanted a reading. The Omron Gold is the one that feels familiar. You press the button, the reading shows on the device, and the routine is the same one you may have used at your doctor's office. If you already know you will never open an app, this is the part that matters, and it matters more than any feature list.
The Omron Gold also wins on buying it in person. Gene and I drove to the pharmacy on a Saturday in March, and I stood in the aisle and put my hand on the box. That is worth something when you are 67 and you want to know the cuff will fit your arm before you spend anything. I asked the pharmacist behind the counter whether the cuff would fit an arm like mine, and she turned the box around and pointed to the range printed on the side. You cannot do that with a listing on a screen. The Withings is easy to order, but you are buying it from a page and a size chart, and if the cuff comes up short you are the one boxing it back up. The other place the Omron Gold wins is the display. The reading appears on the device itself and stays there, so you can take a reading with a phone nowhere near you and no app open. If your eyes are not what they used to be, or you do not want to wear your glasses to the kitchen table at six in the morning, that is a real advantage. The Withings display is fine, but it is small, and the log it feeds is on your phone. The Omron Gold is built around the idea that the device is the whole experience rather than a doorway to an app. For some people, that is exactly right, and I would not talk them out of it.
If you want the log to build itself, start with the Withings BPM Connect
The cuff syncs over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth to the Health Mate app, so your morning and evening readings are waiting when you sit down with your notebook. Check the current price and the 22-42 cm band size on Amazon.
Amazon Check the Withings BPM Connect on Amazon →The best monitor is the one you will actually use twice a day, not the one with the longest feature list.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Withings BPM Connect if you are going to check twice a day for a few weeks and you want the log handled for you. It suits the person who will use the Health Mate app, who likes the idea of readings syncing over Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, and who wants one cuff that covers a 22-42 cm arm range. It also suits a couple like us, where one monitor and one log cover two people and neither of you has to keep a separate notebook. The 2 year manufacturer warranty and the included charger are the kind of details that stop mattering the day it arrives and start mattering the day something goes wrong. Buy the Omron Gold if you want a monitor that works on its own, with the reading shown on the device and no app to set up, and if you want to see the box in a pharmacy and ask a question before you pay. Before you decide, answer two questions honestly. First, will you open the app and look at the log, or will you write the numbers in a notebook? Second, will you keep the cuff where you can reach it in the morning, or does it need to fit in a drawer that is already full? If you will use the app, the Withings is the better fit. If you will not, the Omron Gold is the better fit. If you honestly cannot say, buy whichever one you will set up the day it arrives, because a monitor still in the box at the end of the week measures nothing at all. Either way, bring the readings to your doctor, and do not change anything about your routine or your medicine because of a home monitor without talking to your doctor first.
Bring your doctor a log, not a guess
If you are going to check twice a day for a few weeks, make the record easy on yourself. The Withings BPM Connect puts the numbers in one place and keeps the cuff in the kitchen drawer until morning. Check today's price on Amazon.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →